How a lot are car insurance costs rising on account of poor credit? – Forbes
Editor's Note: We earn a commission through affiliate links on Forbes Advisor. Commissions do not affect the opinions or ratings of our editors.
Speeding tickets, accidents, and the car you drive all affect your car insurance rates, but, surprisingly, your creditworthiness as well.
Forbes Advisor's analysis of auto insurance rates in the 46 states that allow credit as a pricing factor shows an average rate increase of 76% for those with poor creditworthiness. That's an average increase of nearly $ 1,180 per year.
The use of credit in car insurance pricing has been controversial for a number of reasons. The main reason is that loans have nothing to do with the way you drive. However, auto insurance companies point to research showing that credit-based insurance reviews are a good indicator of whether a driver is making claims.
Insurance companies cite various studies that show that drivers with poor credit ratings are more likely to make claims, which means that those drivers pose a higher risk to them and may be more expensive to insure. The more risks and costs you bear, the higher your car insurance rates are.
Best auto insurances 2021
With so many options for car insurance, it can be difficult knowing where to start to find the right car insurance. We rated insurers to find the best auto insurance companies so you don't have to.
How Does Bad Credit Affect Car Insurance?
Auto insurance’s use of loans may seem tedious, but the insurance industry claims the data supports it.
Studies, such as a report frequently referred to the Federal Trade Commission, find a relationship between the number and cost of claims and a driver's creditworthiness. Following this logic, drivers with poor credit ratings are considered to be at higher risk, so in most states you will pay higher auto insurance premiums.
On the other side of the problem are consumer organizations like the Consumer Federation of America, which have argued for years that the use of credit as a valuation factor for auto insurance is fundamentally discriminatory.
Some states agree that using a driver loan is not the best practice.
California, Hawaii, Massachusetts, and Michigan all prohibit the use of credit to determine auto insurance rates. There have been other state and even federal legislative discussions about banning credit as a valuation factor for auto insurance, but none have been put into law.
Average Bad Credit Auto Insurance Rate Increase by State
Our analysis of the 46 states that allow credit-based auto insurance ratings in determining auto insurance rates shows that the five states with the lowest average annual increase for bad credit scores are below 50%. New York has the smallest increase. The remaining states with the lowest average annual increases for bad credit are:
- New York: 33%
- Wyoming: 39%
- Florida: 42%
- North Carolina: 44%
- Washington: 47%
The five states with the highest average annual increase double the cost of insurance for drivers with poor credit ratings. Arkansas has the highest rise. The states with the highest average annual increases are:
- Arkansas: 110%
- South Dakota: 109%
- Nebraska: 108%
- Wisconsin: 105%
- Utah: 104%
When looking at the increase by dollar amount, Wyoming has the lowest increase ($ 539) while Louisiana has the highest ($ 2,768).
The average car insurance rate increases with poor creditworthiness
How long can bad credit affect my auto insurance rates?
Unlike traffic tickets, which usually lose your driving records and don't affect tariffs after three to five years, poor credit can continuously affect your car insurance tariffs.
As long as you have poor credit, your car insurance rates can be affected.
The best way to keep your credit from increasing your auto insurance premiums is to increase your score. Once you have successfully increased your score, it is a good time to compare car insurance quotes.
If you wait to shop until the next renewal period, ask your current auto insurance company to check your balance as some only check for changes every few years if you're a long-time customer.
You should see your rates improve with your current insurance company as your credit improves – but also take the time to look around. If there is a positive change in credit, another company may offer you cheaper rates and is better overall for your needs.
How does bad credit compare to tickets, accidents, or a DUI for auto insurance rates?
Bad credit increases your rates more than a traffic ticket or accident, and possibly more than a DUI, depending on where you live and your company's rating system.
Our analysis found that car insurance rates for bad credit increase an average of 76% per year, while car insurance rates for a parking ticket only increase 21%. The average rate increase after a negligent accident is 41%.
A DUI is a grave misdemeanor with many consequences, including an average increase in car insurance rates of 74%, which is still below the 76% increase we've seen in bad credit drivers.
However, in some states, a DUI increases your premium significantly compared to the average increase for bad credit. We have found that this is particularly true in states where credit is not used for rating purposes. These four states that prohibit the use of credit have had above-average rate hikes for DUIs:
- California: 154%
- Hawaii: 134%
- Massachusetts: 91%
- Michigan: 193%
In some states that allow credit as a rating factor, we found that the rate hike for a DUI was much higher than the lending rate hike. Some examples are:
- New York with a 68% rate hike for a DUI versus 33% for a bad credit rating
- North Carolina, with a 319% increase for DUI versus 44% for poor credit
- Wyoming, with a 56% increase for DUI versus 39% for bad credit.
To get better rates in each state, keep a clean driving log and work towards good or excellent credit. You want to generate a low-risk profile for car insurance in order to offer you affordable prices.
How can I lower my car insurance rates even if I have a bad credit rating?
Bad credit doesn't define you – it's just one aspect of the overall package that auto insurance companies look at. There are ways to lower your car insurance rates.
To get better prices even with bad credit ratings, you can:
- Ask about discounts. Don't be shy with your agent or your insurance company: ask if there are discounts on auto insurance that you are entitled to and that you don't get. You can easily pay paperless or in full, or you can bundle your car insurance with your home insurance to get discounts on your premium.
- Show that you are a good driver. If you'd like driving factors to count more towards your car insurance, try signing up for a usage-based car insurance program. The insurance company monitors your driving behavior. If you do well, you can get up to 40% off some vendors.
- Check your insurance policy. Your needs may have changed since you got your car insurance, so double check. If you have an older car and don't need collision and fully comprehensive insurance, you can take it off and save.
- Comparison shop. This is the most important tip. You won't get the cheapest car insurance rates without buying from multiple companies. Every insurer weights rating factors such as creditworthiness differently. So make sure to shop at least once a year to make sure you get the best price.
Increase in car insurance rate by company due to poor creditworthiness
When analyzing the tariffs of some of the best auto insurance companies, we discovered a wide range of premiums for drivers with poor credit ratings. We found Geico to have the cheapest average annual prices of $ 1,750 and car owners the most expensive at $ 3,970. That's a difference of $ 2,220.
With a difference of 127% between the cheapest and the most expensive, the premium offer underscores the importance of the comparison purchase for car insurance.
Among the companies we analyzed, Nationwide (35%) is the company with the lowest percentage increase among drivers with poor credit ratings. But Nationwide doesn't have the lowest overall rate for bad credit drivers – Geico beat it by $ 155. This shows why it is important to consider the total premium when comparing costs and not just the possible savings through discounts or the level of the tariffs for certain topics.
Which auto insurers won't check credit reports?
Unless an auto insurance company specifically states that it does not include creditworthiness in its pricing, it is best to assume that all of these are the case if your state allows your credit history as a rating factor.
There are currently four states – California, Hawaii, Massachusetts, and Michigan – that do not allow creditworthiness to determine auto insurance rates. So if you live in one of these states, all auto insurance companies should skip checking credit history when calculating rates.
Some other states restrict the options of insurance companies with credit scores.
For example, Maryland prohibits auto insurance companies from using credit history to determine whether they are insuring you, canceling your policy, renewing your policy, or increasing your premium once a policy goes into effect. However, laws allow a credit check when you first apply for a policy and they dictate what you pay at the start of the policy.
Maryland law also requires insurance companies to tell applicants whether credit history affects rates and how much your rate depends on your creditworthiness.
Many state laws require auto insurance providers to disclose that your credit report can be verified and notify you if it results in an adverse measure, such as higher rates.
Frequently asked questions about low credit auto insurance
Is There a Difference Between a Credit Score and an Insurance Score?
Yes sir. Insurance companies don't use your credit score (like your FICO score), but they do calculate an insurance score.
Your credit score is about your credit score and the likelihood of missing out on payments. A credit-based insurance score uses your credit history, but focuses on predicting the likelihood of you making a claim in the near future.
Insurance companies and the data analytics companies they buy information from, such as LexisNexis, do not disclose details of how insurance ratings are calculated – the information is proprietary. However, according to the Insurance Information Institute, the following factors can be included in the assessment:
- Length of credit history
- Late payments
- Number of installment accounts
- Collections and bankruptcies
- New loan applications
- Types of credit used
- Unused credit
Why is the use of credit-based scores for insurance tariffs controversial?
It's a complex situation, but in short, the practice is controversial as critics say the use of socio-economic factors in car insurance pricing increases tariffs for low-income drivers despite clean driving records. The insurance industry argues the data isn't unfairly discriminatory, but consumer protection groups say the tariffs show otherwise.
In general, many consumer advocates are against the use of non-driving pricing factors in auto insurance. Insurance companies claim that non-driving factors such as creditworthiness, age, marital status, and place of residence can help insurance companies predict losses and therefore better evaluate policies. Some even use the profession and level of education.
The future may bring changes as insurance regulators have committed to reviewing current practices that may disadvantage minorities.
Will a car insurance offer damage my creditworthiness?
No. The credit check by a car insurance company is a "soft move" that does not affect your creditworthiness.
A "hard pull" or request – for example, one made by a credit card company when you apply for a card – will result in a record of the event in your creditworthiness that can affect your score. A gentle pull doesn't affect your creditworthiness.
That said, it's perfectly fine to seek auto insurance quotes from many different insurers in order to find the right price for your budget.